Safety Bulletin | Flight Planning & Mountainous Terrain | Tatenhill Aviation
Safety Bulletin

Flight Planning &
Mountainous Terrain

Moving maps have transformed the way we plan and navigate, but good flight planning remains much more than drawing a straight line between two airfields.

Tatenhill Aviation Threat & Error Management Flight Planning Mountain Flying

A timely reminder

The recent tragic accident involving an aircraft based at Tatenhill routing to Caernarfon reminds us all that aviation and safety have to be respected at all times.

This bulletin does not seek to speculate about the circumstances of that accident or criticise the actions of the pilot involved. We do not know the circumstances of that flight, and an accident can happen to any of us.

What the accident has done is bring renewed attention to an area that has caused some concern over recent months when speaking with renters: flight planning.


More than stretching a line across a tablet

Moving map technology has made flying considerably easier and, used correctly, provides pilots with an extremely valuable tool.

The danger is that flight planning can gradually become little more than stretching a few lines across a tablet, checking the weather at the destination, reviewing the NOTAMs and deciding that the planning is complete.

A magenta line tells you where you want to go. It does not tell you whether going there is a good idea.

We have seen examples during the summer of renters planning flights from Tatenhill to Caernarfon using an almost direct route across Snowdonia.

A direct route may be perfectly achievable in suitable conditions. The important question is whether the threats associated with that route have actually been identified and managed.

What could change the plan?

Threat and Error Management should form part of every flight, particularly where the terrain significantly reduces your options.

Weather

Cloud base, visibility, wind, turbulence, mountain wave, precipitation and changing conditions.

Terrain

High ground, valleys, escape routes, forced-landing options and terrain clearance.

Fuel

Planned burn, climbing fuel, diversion fuel and an appropriate reserve.

Diversion Options

Where can you go if the route ahead becomes unavailable?

Route

Is the shortest route actually the safest route?

Airspace

Controlled, restricted or other airspace that may reduce your options.

System Failure

Moving-map failure, GNSS loss, overheating, flat batteries or other equipment problems.

Human Factors

Experience, fatigue, workload, distraction, recency and personal skill level.

This bulletin is not intended to cover every element of flight planning. However, proper planning should be thorough.

For a significant landaway flight, the planning process can take almost as long as the flight itself. Many renters already demonstrate excellent planning, including mass and balance and aircraft performance calculations.


Imagine you were crossing the Channel

Most pilots naturally adopt a different mindset when planning a flight across the English Channel.

Engine Failure

What if the engine stops?

  • Fly as high as reasonably practical to increase glide range.
  • Consider the shortest practical water crossing.
  • Understand the point of no return.
  • Consider available diversion and landing options.
Weather

What if the weather deteriorates?

  • Can you turn back safely?
  • Where are your planned alternates?
  • Have you carried sufficient additional fuel?
  • What will you do if your preferred route becomes unavailable?

Flying over hills and mountains deserves the same level of thought.

Crossing Snowdonia, the Pennines, Cairngorms or other significant terrain may not involve an expanse of water beneath you, but it can reduce your escape, diversion and forced-landing options just as dramatically.


Give yourself margin

Normal VFR terrain clearance requirements still apply, but in mountainous areas a clearance of around 2,000 ft can provide a greater margin against turbulence and descending air associated with downdrafts or mountain waves.

Significant mountain-wave effects can be encountered within and downwind of terrain that might not initially appear particularly imposing.

The fact that an aircraft can physically out-climb the terrain in still air does not mean it will necessarily be able to do so in significant descending air.

Low cloud and mountainous terrain

Low cloud over mountainous terrain presents a serious risk.

Before committing to the route, you should be confident that there is no significant cloud at your intended operating altitude along the route.

Unlike operating over relatively flat terrain, your options for descending, manoeuvring or reversing course may become very limited if you encounter instrument meteorological conditions.

Always preserve a margin of clear air between the aircraft and the cloud base above.

Cloud base can vary considerably over surprisingly short distances in mountainous areas. Valleys may also fill with fog even when skies elsewhere appear relatively clear.

Continuing into a lowering cloud base can ultimately lead to controlled flight into terrain or loss of control following an inadvertent entry into IMC.

What is underneath you?

Significant cloud below the aircraft should also prompt careful consideration.

Ask yourself what you would do if an emergency required you to descend or make a forced landing.

Entering cloud in temperatures below freezing may also result in ice formation, reducing aircraft performance and potentially creating control difficulties.

Forced Landing

Look beyond the cruise portion of the flight

If finding a suitable field during a practice forced landing around Tatenhill can sometimes be challenging, consider how limited those options may become over mountainous terrain.


Mountain wave and rotor

Mountain flying is generally more straightforward with low wind speeds and minimal cloud, conditions which may often be more likely earlier in the day.

When winds aloft become significant, turbulence and downdrafts should be expected.

A stable airflow crossing high ground can generate a standing mountain wave.

As a useful rule of thumb, when wind at ridge or mountain-top height is around 15 knots or more, particularly where a ridge lies broadly perpendicular to the wind, consider the possibility of mountain wave downwind.

An aircraft flying through the descending portion of the wave may be unable to climb and may even be unable to maintain altitude.

This could prevent the aircraft clearing terrain or leave it dangerously low within a valley with few or no landing options.

Beneath the wave, extremely rough air known as rotor may also be present and should be avoided where possible.


The nearest airfield may not be the easiest airfield

Consider your diversion options before departure rather than waiting until the route ahead becomes unusable.

As the flight progresses you may pass aerodromes that could provide useful diversion options.

In mountainous terrain, however, the route to the geographically nearest aerodrome may itself be blocked by high ground or poor weather.

The safest option may involve carefully reversing course and routing to an aerodrome that is physically further away.

A diversion in mountainous terrain may therefore add considerably more flying time than expected. Account for this when planning fuel.

Remember also to account for the additional fuel used during prolonged climbs.


Use the moving map — don't depend on it

Moving-map displays are a valuable aid when operating around mountainous terrain, but they should not become the sole means of planning and navigation.

  • Enable terrain depiction or warning features where available.
  • Configure the device before departure to minimise adjustments during flight.
  • Keep your eyes outside the aircraft and use the moving map periodically to verify position and orientation.
  • Maintain separation from terrain visually, using terrain warnings as an additional safety mitigation.
  • Before changing route, establish that the new flight path is clear of terrain before becoming occupied with the device.
  • Be prepared to revert to conventional navigation and dead reckoning.
  • Remember that devices can overheat, lose power or become difficult to read in strong sunlight.
Technology should support your situational awareness, not replace it.

Look at the bigger picture

Pilots are strongly encouraged to review and carry the relevant ICAO VFR chart alongside flight-planning software.

Sometimes significant information is simply more obvious when viewed on the chart.

A paper chart can also provide a much better overall appreciation of the relationship between terrain, airspace, aerodromes and possible diversion routes.


Direct — or ten minutes longer?

Having considered all of the above, conditions may be entirely suitable to route directly to Caernarfon and enjoy some spectacular views over the hills.

But Threat and Error Management may lead you to a different conclusion.

Consider the alternative

What about routing around the North Wales coast?

It may require nothing more than a little extra “elastic banding” of the route on the moving map and perhaps around ten additional minutes of flying.

In return, you may gain considerably more options should the weather deteriorate, the aircraft develop a problem or the flight simply not proceed as planned.

And the views aren't bad either.

Plan for the flight you might have — not just the flight you want

Good flight planning is not about finding reasons not to fly. It is about understanding the threats, building options into the flight and ensuring that when something changes, you are already ahead of the aircraft.

The shortest route is not always the safest route, and a few extra minutes in the air can buy you a lot more options.